‘Hadestown’ Brings Broadway’s Underworld to the Big Screen: Original Cast Members and Creator Anaïs Mitchell on Reconvening for a Smashing Cinema Event
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Hadestown: The Musical is predicted to earn around $9 million at the U.S. box office this weekend, a figure that would rank it behind only the theatrical opening of the Hamilton film among direct captures of stage productions.
- Reeve Carney, Eva Noblezada, Patrick Page, André De Shields, and Amber Gray — the five original Broadway principals — reunited to perform the film at London's Lyric Theatre across three live audiences, a project that was originally attempted in winter 2022 before Gray was about to leave the show.
- Carney describes the filming as 'a Herculean task,' noting that 4-6 cameras ran simultaneously during the Friday night, Saturday matinee, and Saturday evening performances, with cameras repositioned to an entirely different part of the theater for each show — effectively a 30-camera shoot with one take per shot.
- Anaïs Mitchell says the film's close-ups deliver emotional access — tears rolling down cheeks, lips twitching — that theatergoers couldn't catch, while director Brett Sullivan still incorporates audience reaction shots and long views of the stage to preserve the live context.
- Patrick Page explains that the close-ups reveal subtext and unspoken exchanges between the original cast — glances, phrasing — that were always there but invisible even from the fourth or fifth row, with Page noting he couldn't 'cheat' the way he sometimes could performing eight shows a week.
- Now married, Carney and Noblezada credit the fan-driven 'Reeva' phenomenon — Noblezada wore a 'Reeva' T-shirt during the interview — while Carney reframes Hadestown as optimistic rather than tragic, a piece designed to 'empower and embolden people to make a different decision.'
Why it matters: A potential $9M opening would rank Hadestown second only to Hamilton among filmed stage productions, validating theatrical captures as viable summer counterprogramming to blockbusters like The Odyssey. The original Broadway cast's reunion — delayed from a 2022 attempt when Amber Gray was leaving — delivers a definitive version fans never got to see on stage, and the close-up format surfaces emotional layers that even front-row audiences missed.
