ESPN opposes access limits in Miami murder trial
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- ESPN, NBCUniversal Media (owner of NBC6 South Florida), and McClatchy Company (publisher of the Miami Herald) filed a joint motion Thursday opposing potential media access limits ahead of a Monday hearing before Judge Cristina Miranda.
- Judge Cristina Miranda of Florida's 11th Circuit Court raised the possibility of restricting media access and imposing a gag order, citing concerns about social media disclosures that could affect jury selection in the Rashaun Jones retrial.
- The media motion cites the "well-established presumption that pretrial proceedings and trials are open to the public" and argues gag orders are unconstitutional prior restraints, noting Florida courts rejected similar bans in the Parkland school shooting and Ted Bundy cases.
- Rashaun Jones' defense attorney Sara Alvarez filed a separate motion Wednesday stating Jones "welcomes the scrutiny of the press" and affirmatively opposes any closure of proceedings.
- The Miami-Dade State Attorney's Office has not stated a position on media restrictions but last month asked the judge to order defense attorneys to turn over any correspondence with reporters and records of communications with law enforcement officers.
- Jones was arrested in 2021 after an ESPN investigation showed police considered him a suspect early on; no arrest was made for 15 years, and his first trial ended in a hung jury before the retrial was pushed from May to September.
- New issues in the retrial include an internal police probe into the lead detective's alleged use of an anonymous social media account to comment on the defendant, a Florida Bar misconduct complaint against the former lead prosecutor, and the reintroduction of a jailhouse informant who claims Jones confessed in 2022.
Why it matters: The motion puts three major media organizations on record fighting to keep a 2006 murder retrial — already marked by a 15-year investigative gap and fresh misconduct allegations against police and prosecutors — open to public view. If Judge Miranda grants restrictions anyway, it narrows press access to a case that involves questions about law enforcement conduct spanning more than a decade and a recent deposition leaked by a YouTube personality.
Ask SkimNews
