Scaloni and De la Fuente beat Tuchel and Ancelotti at World Cup
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Lionel Scaloni and Luis de la Fuente will meet in Sunday's World Cup final having never managed a top-flight club game between them, with one falling into the job as a caretaker and the other promoted from Spain's U21s.
- Scaloni took over Argentina as caretaker in 2018 after they had gone a quarter-century without a major trophy; he has since delivered the 2021 Copa America, 2022 World Cup and 2024 Copa America and is chasing a fourth straight title.
- De la Fuente replaced Luis Enrique in 2023, won the Nations League within six months, claimed Euro 2024 and has now guided Spain past France in the semi-finals — with Rodri saying Spain played "even better without the ball than with it."
- Tuchel (formerly of Chelsea, PSG and Bayern) was held responsible for England's semi-final exit, while Carlo Ancelotti (five-time Champions League winner) failed to get Brazil past the last 16 and Mauricio Pochettino's USA fell at the same stage.
- Julian Nagelsmann departed the Germany job after a round-of-32 loss to Paraguay and Marcelo Bielsa left Uruguay after a group-stage exit, compounding the struggles of managers hired on club-level pedigree.
- Both Scaloni and De la Fuente built their projects on togetherness rather than CVs — De la Fuente knew much of his squad from a decade coaching Spain's U19s and U21s, while Scaloni's players including Nicolas Otamendi and Emi Martinez say they "would give their lives for him."
- Scaloni's tactical flexibility — defending deep, dominating possession or playing on the break — was praised by Alexis Mac Allister and Javier Mascherano, distinguishing him from predecessors like Gareth Southgate who were seen to lack that acumen.
Why it matters: The article explicitly contrasts federations that hired big-name club managers — England (Tuchel), Brazil (Ancelotti), USA (Pochettino), Germany (Nagelsmann) and Uruguay (Bielsa) — all of whom exited the tournament, against Argentina and Spain, who reached the final with coaches built on trust, long-term player relationships and tactical adaptability rather than star CVs. The second-order consequence: federations defaulting to marquee club hires may be overlooking the specific conditions that actually win international tournaments.
