Butler book traces culture war roots from Mapplethorpe to Trump
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Isaac Butler published "The Perfect Moment: God, Sex, Art, and the Birth of America's Culture Wars," arguing the late 1980s was "world war one" of the modern culture wars, framing today's battles as world war two.
- Butler was spurred to write the book in 2020 after the National Gallery of Art postponed a Philip Guston retrospective over fears that Guston's Klan imagery was not "sufficiently clear in their anti-racist point of view," despite Guston being a lifelong anti-racist and Jewish artist whose early works were destroyed by the KKK.
- Rev. Donald Wildmon of Tupelo, Mississippi became a central architect of the movement, targeting NEA-funded art through "misrepresenting the art through taking pieces of it out of context" — and once sent Andres Serrano's "Piss Christ" image to every member of Congress, according to Butler.
- Senator Jesse Helms urged Republicans to abandon "conciliatory centrists" and recognized that the arts were one of the few public spaces where Aids and LGBTQ+ perspectives were being expressed, making them a deliberate target for suppression.
- The Corcoran Gallery of Art pre-emptively cancelled its 1989 Robert Mapplethorpe retrospective "The Perfect Moment" before it opened, giving the religious right a "monumental victory" and proving the arts establishment would censor itself under pressure.
- Butler identifies two fatal flaws in the liberal response that "continue to plague the Democratic party today": underestimating opponents as "yokels" and a "fetishisation of compromise" that signals vulnerability and invites further attacks.
- Butler draws a direct line to the current Trump administration, noting it didn't need to pass laws banning transgender rights on campuses — instead threatening to cut university research funding unless they complied with single-sex bathroom demands, weaponizing money's "coercive" power.
Why it matters: Butler's history suggests the Trump administration's strategy of threatening to strip federal research funding from universities — rather than passing explicit speech bans — isn't a new tactic but the direct descendant of the 1980s playbook that succeeded against the Corcoran and the NEA Four. The arts failed to build a permanent activist constituency after those battles, leaving cultural institutions vulnerable to the same coercive-money pressure that shut down Mapplethorpe 36 years ago.
