Rachel Reid Fires Back at Heated Rivalry Season 2 Casting Critics
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Justice Smith and Charlie Gillespie have been cast as Harris Drover and Troy Barrett in Heated Rivalry Season 2, the roles Reid's Instagram Story framed as a callback to last summer's 'wrong and bad' casting complaints about Ilya and Shane.
- Rachel Reid posted a side-eye selfie on Instagram Story after Season 2 casting backlash, writing she was 'thinking about all the people last summer who told me the casting for Ilya and Shane was wrong and bad.'
- Season 2 adapts Role Model, the fifth book in Reid's bestselling Game Changer series, in which Troy is a hockey teammate of Ilya's carrying a history of bullying and Harris is the team's social media manager.
- Season 1 became an overnight hit based on the series' second book, with Connor Storrie and Hudson Williams playing Ilya Rozanov and Shane Hollander in performances that launched their Hollywood profiles.
- Series creator Jacob Tierney and executive producer Brendan Brady released a joint statement calling Harris and Troy 'beautifully layered characters' and praising Smith and Gillespie for connecting with the characters' 'vulnerability and resilience.'
- Production on the sophomore season began in Canada earlier this week, with the Crave Original slated to premiere in spring 2027.
Why it matters: Reid's public clap-back signals she and the producers are willing to break the reflexive fan-casting cycle, doubling down on chemistry reads over book-accurate look-alikes. With Season 1 launching Storrie and Williams into mainstream Hollywood, the new leads now inherit a fandom that has already proven it can break or build careers through online sentiment.
Ask SkimNews
