Why TV Is Obsessed With Amateur Detectives
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- High Potential, Elsbeth, and Ludwig are among recent shows built around hyper-talented civilians solving crimes alongside police, a template TV Tropes labels "No badge? No problem!" — a mother-of-three cleaner with a 160 IQ, a DOJ-mandated lawyer, and a reclusive puzzle-maker impersonating his detective twin, respectively.
- The archetype traces to Edgar Allan Poe's C. Auguste Dupin (1841–1844), who used deduction to help the Paris gendarmerie solve seemingly impossible crimes, and was codified by Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes, who in 1887's A Study in Scarlet declared himself a "consulting detective" the police turn to when "at fault."
- The BBC has announced a new Hercule Poirot reimagined as a "handsome thirtysomething private detective," prompting Metro to object: "We don't need a young and sexy Hercule Poirot." A third Enola Holmes instalment is also out this week, and spring's surprise film hit was The Sheep Detectives, in which sheep help a bumbling policeman catch their shepherd's killer.
- A surge of female consultant detectives — Elsbeth, High Potential's Morgan Gillory, and the BBC's newly announced The Hairdresser Mysteries with Sally Phillips as a village salon-owner-sleuth — reflects a broader shift to "women-centred" storytelling, with warmth and empathy framed as their investigative superpower.
- A Metropolitan police detective consulted for the article said the consulting sleuth "exists purely in fiction" and resents portrayals where detectives can "just tell" someone is lying — her training focused on evidence, not intuition.
- Real forensic experts like Dr. Lorraine Sheridan, a former behavioural investigative adviser, and gait-analysis podiatrists do assist police, but Sheridan said the reality — no hot desk, no ongoing partnership, no coffee banter — "looked nothing like what we see on screen," and civilian investigators introduced amid detective shortages only handle low-level offences like shop theft.
Why it matters: The consulting detective has become television's dominant crime-solving template because it packages an outsider's brilliance — particularly women's empathy in newer iterations — with minimal procedural friction. But every real expert the writer consulted stressed the gap with actual policing, where specialist consultants contribute narrow expertise rather than serving as all-purpose mystery solvers whose hunches close cases.
