Hüller Stars in Pawlikowski's Cannes 'Fatherland'
SkimNews Take
Hüller's portrayal of the daughter as an intellectual force challenging the father's narrative suggests the film explores the generational and gendered re-evaluation of post-war German identity.
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Pawlikowski's "Fatherland" is a monochrome, co-written film shot by cinematographer Lukasz Zal, starring Sandra Hüller as Erika Mann and Hanns Zischler as her father Thomas Mann, and premiered at Cannes.
- Set in 1949, the film follows Thomas Mann — a German Nobel laureate in American exile since fleeing the Nazis — as he accepts a Goethe award in Frankfurt in the West, then crosses into communist East Germany to accept a second award in Weimar.
- Erika (Hüller) is racked with anguish over her brother Klaus (August Diehl), a writer in American exile suffering depression and drug dependency, with whom she shares a bleak phone-call duet that opens the film.
- Klaus's novel "Mephisto" — about a vain actor who sells out to the Nazis, based on Erika's ex-husband Gustaf Gründgens (Joachim Meyerhoff) — becomes a "Mephisto crisis" that implicitly indicts Thomas's diplomatic neutrality and colossal literary prestige.
- Gründgens brazenly shows up to the Frankfurt celebration and attempts banter with Erika, who slaps him; in a parallel scene, Thomas tells Wagner's grandchildren the Bayreuth theatre should be burned down.
- A German correspondent at a Frankfurt press conference reproaches Mann for not choosing the path of "internal emigration" within Germany, to which Mann replies that without leaving he would not have survived.
- Bach's music is the one source of emotional release the film offers both father and daughter, in an otherwise taut, un-emollient picture.
Why it matters: The film uses Mann's 1949 visit to argue that literary prestige and diplomatic neutrality can amount to a political evasion — and that a son's costlier engagement, measured through the "Mephisto" crisis, indicts the father. It positions Pawlikowski and Hüller as Cannes mainstays turning the Mann family tragedy into an allegory for a Germany whose cultural inheritance was contaminated by the Cold War and the Holocaust.
