Intermittent fasting matches calorie counting for weight loss
Get the Health newsletter
Daily health & science — research, biotech, public health, the studies worth knowing. Free.
- University of Adelaide researchers found in an 18-month trial of more than 200 adults with obesity that intermittent fasting and continuous calorie restriction produced nearly identical weight loss — roughly 7 kilograms at six months — versus about 2 kg for a standard-care group that only received healthy eating guidelines.
- Professor Leonie Heilbronn and colleagues calculated that the psychological burden of constantly monitoring intake accounted for roughly 15% of weight loss in the calorie-restriction group, while intermittent fasters reported no comparable feeling of ongoing control over their eating.
- The intermittent fasting protocol required participants to consume 30% of their daily energy needs between 8am and 12pm on three non-consecutive days each week, followed by a 20-hour fast, with normal eating on the remaining four days.
- Participants in both diet groups reported improvements in depression symptoms and overall well-being — including on fasting days — alongside their weight loss, according to findings published in the journal Clinical Nutrition.
- Heilbronn called for future trials to identify individuals who specifically struggle to change eating behaviors, arguing they may do better with fasting-based approaches and enabling more personalized weight management.
Why it matters: The 18-month trial isolates a core failure point of obesity treatment — not whether diets work, but whether people sustain them. With both approaches yielding ~7 kg loss at six months but intermittent fasters reporting far less mental burden, clinicians gain a potentially more viable option for the millions of patients who repeatedly lose and regain weight on traditional diets.
