Model Calls Nabers, James Cook 2026 Fantasy Busts
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- SportsLine's model simulated the 2026 NFL season 10,000 times and identified Giants WR Malik Nabers as a top bust despite an ADP around pick No. 33, ranking him outside the top 15 receivers and behind DeVonta Smith and Nico Collins due to his ACL recovery and a run-heavy Giants scheme under OC Matt Nagy.
- Bills RB James Cook was flagged as a second bust, going off boards at ADP No. 11 overall but ranked only RB10 by the model behind Derrick Henry and Chase Brown, with fumble rate and Josh Allen's goal-line poaching cited as factors.
- Terry McLaurin's 2025 collapse — career lows of 582 receiving yards and 3 TDs after a 1,100-yard, 13-TD season — was called by the same model, which also identified A.J. Brown as a 2020 sleeper, predicted Jonathan Taylor's 2021 monster year, and pegged C.J. Stroud for a 2024 regression.
- The model is fading one of the first five wide receivers off draft boards in 2026, ranking him barely inside the top 10 and calling him one of the biggest busts of the year, though his identity is gated behind a SportsLine subscription.
- Top of the 2026 CBS PPR ADP board is led by Jahmyr Gibbs (1.24), Bijan Robinson (1.94), Ja'Marr Chase (3.99), Puka Nacua (5.20), and Jonathan Taylor (5.23), with the NFL regular season set to open Wednesday, Sept. 9.
Why it matters: Fantasy drafters who lean on ADP consensus face material risk: two players currently going in the top 33 picks (Nabers, Cook) are ranked materially lower by a model with a verifiable multi-year track record, including correctly fading McLaurin a year ago. If the model is right, second-round picks based on ADP could swing league outcomes and waste early capital on recovering or touchdown-dependent players.
Ask SkimNews
