Taylor-Joy cast as original elf in Serkis's 'Hunt for
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Anya Taylor-Joy has been cast as Seren, an original elven character who does not appear in Tolkien's writings, in "The Hunt for Gollum," as confirmed this week by The Hollywood Reporter.
- Seren is described as a "trusted, lethal agent" of elvenking Thranduil — again played by Lee Pace — and is a Sindar elf, one of the clan that stayed behind in Middle-earth, likely hailing from the forest of Mirkwood.
- Andy Serkis returns to the role of Gollum while also directing, with Ian McKellen reprising Gandalf and Jamie Dornan stepping into Aragorn's boots for a storyline Tolkien himself covered in only a handful of pages.
- Peter Jackson serves as a producer on the project, which dramatizes the roughly two-decade hunt for Gollum between Bilbo's departure for Rivendell and the events of "The Lord of the Rings."
- The piece argues the film amounts to "expensive gap-filler" retreading the same swampy ground Jackson already covered in "The Two Towers" and "The Return of the King" — a brooding chase thriller that may be superbly realized but still "no closer to understanding quite why the whole thing actually needs to happen."
Why it matters: This is a contrarian opinion piece that runs against the celebratory tone of most coverage of Taylor-Joy's casting. By highlighting that Seren doesn't exist in Tolkien's source material and that the hunt-for-Gollum arc was deliberately compressed by the original author, the review frames the film as a franchise-extending exercise rather than essential storytelling — a skepticism that could temper fan and box-office expectations for Warner Bros.' latest Tolkien bet.
