π Was 2011 the best NFL draft defensive class?
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports β scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- The 1981 draft class set the benchmark with six Hall of Famers β Lawrence Taylor, Kenny Easley, Ronnie Lott, Mike Singletary, Howie Long, and Rickey Jackson β plus posthumous inductee Sam Mills, and no class since the 1970 merger has matched that total.
- The 2011 draft was shaped by the expiring CBA and lockout: Cam Newton's rookie deal dropped to four years and $22 million from Sam Bradford's six-year, $78 million contract the year prior, and teams drafted before the free agency window opened.
- Ten defenders from the 2011 class earned at least one first-team All-Pro selection, topping the 1981 class's count, and the group wasn't a product of weak surrounding drafts β the 2010 class produced 18 All-Pro nods across eight players and 2012 produced 20, including Hall of Famer Luke Kuechly.
- J.J. Watt racked up 69 sacks, 190 quarterback hits, and 119 tackles for loss between 2012 and 2015, with the author calling him the most dominant defender he'd covered in nearly two decades, before injuries derailed his career.
- Von Miller ranks ninth all-time with 138.5 career sacks, won Super Bowl MVP with 2.5 sacks against the Panthers in Super Bowl 50, and added a second ring with the Rams; he's a free agent coming off a nine-sack season.
- Patrick Peterson made eight straight Pro Bowls to start his career β only three other players with 8-for-8 Pro Bowl starts aren't yet Hall-eligible (Aaron Donald, Tyreek Hill, Quenton Nelson), and all are expected first-ballot selections.
- Cameron Heyward and Cameron Jordan are the only 2011 defenders still active, and the author expects Hall of Fame voting for the class to begin in 2027 β meaning the class's final standing against 1981 could hinge on whether those two eventually join Watt, Miller, Sherman, and Peterson in Canton.
Why it matters: If Heyward and Jordan make the Hall, the 2011 class would produce at least four β and potentially six β defensive inductees, narrowing the gap with the unprecedented 1981 class. With first-team All-Pro defenders from 2010 and 2012 also stacking up (Kuechly already enshrined, Wagner likely next), the 2011 class stands out for its top-end Hall-of-Fame ceiling rather than weak surrounding drafts. For the Steelers and Saints, their aging stars' late-career production now carries historical weight beyond wins and losses.
