Bestseller charts are paid, covers are focus-grouped
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- A commercial publisher's copywriter told the author that cosy crime and romantasy are the industry's main growth areas, with books routinely repackaged to fit trends — including a publisher's 'unspoken imperative' to put a cat on Japanese fiction covers even when no major feline character exists.
- Supermarket bestseller lists are 'very much not earned positions' but are paid for, according to an experienced publicist; a 2022 BBC report found TG Jones (formerly WH Smith) charged publishers for chart space, and Waterstones charged for display tables before James Daunt's takeover.
- Book covers are focus-grouped and routinely changed at the behest of supermarket and chain buyers, designer Jamie Keenan said, with Tesco and Waterstones wielding 'a tremendous amount of clout' — both retailers declined to speak to the author.
- Goldsboro Books runs four subscription book clubs, including a 2,000-member fantasy club and a debut-fiction club approaching 500 members; founder David Headley, who picks all titles himself, said club selection 'can get you into the top 10 bestsellers.'
- Author endorsements on covers function largely as networking favours within author circles, according to literary agent Philip Gwyn Jones and a commercial copywriter, with Stephen King and Tony Parsons cited as names that 'pop up on every single book.'
- Bookseller shelf talkers work 'almost 100% of the time' when short and sincere, but a Waterstones bookseller admitted staff 'steal something off Goodreads' to meet the chain's three-cards-per-shelf-bay quota when no one in the shop has read the title.
- Blurb copy is engineered for the 'F-shaped' reading pattern — hitting key words at the start of paragraphs and avoiding anything that lets a reader put the book down — with cosy crime blurbs reframing violence as a 'minor inconvenience' to fit market conventions.
Why it matters: Readers who think they choose books freely are actually responding to a pipeline of paid chart placements, buyer-vetted covers, copywriter-engineered blurbs, and curated shelf talkers — meaning the bestseller list, long treated as evidence of public taste, is partly a purchased ranking rather than an organic measure of demand.
Ask SkimNews
