Review: Martin & Roman's Irish Road Trip Stumbles on Tone
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Martin and Roman Kemp host Channel 4's "Martin & Roman's Irish Road Trip," airing Mondays at 8pm, but the reviewer questions the casting after the pair reveal a family DNA test showed Germanic rather than Irish ancestry, contradicting Martin's mother's claim of being half Irish.
- The first episode tours Spike Island in Cork Harbour — dubbed "Ireland's Alcatraz" for 1,300 years of prison use — including a seventh-century isolation cell where prisoners, including children, were chained by their necks for weeks as punishment.
- Roman Kemp openly discusses thinking about his own mortality and his parents' future deaths, saying it sometimes keeps him awake at night — a melancholic thread that clashes with the jaunty Irish folk music scoring the journey.
- The reviewer's favorite moments center on the father-son dynamic rather than the Irish content, including a scene where Roman encourages his shy father Martin to knock on a stranger's door to request a key to an ancient tomb.
- The reviewer — self-described as English-Irish with a grandfather who rode in the Grand National and an inherited Waterford crystal whiskey glass — admits they remain a hard sell on two Englishmen exploring Irish folklore, even when the pair engage earnestly with locals.
- Martin Kemp briefly lived in Ireland in the 1980s during his Spandau Ballet era, the sole thin justification offered for the road trip premise.
Why it matters: The review exposes a structural problem with celebrity travelogues built on tenuous cultural credentials: the premise itself becomes the story. Channel 4's investment in a father-son bonding format pays off in small, awkward human moments but undermines the Irish exploration when tonal shifts between cheery fiddle music and grim historical content leave the series unsure what it wants to be.
Ask SkimNews
