RFU councillor resigns over Maggie Alphonsi Facebook
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Matthew Smith, Warwickshire's representative on the 62-strong RFU council, resigned after posting 'can someone please explain to me WTF does Maggie Alphonsi know about men's rugby?' on Facebook during France's 48-46 win over England in March
- Maggie Alphonsi, a 74-cap England World Cup winner, said she felt 'let down' by the three-person disciplinary panel's initial penalty, which only stripped Smith of council perks — England game tickets, free meals, travel — for seven months
- The RFU's women in leadership collective demanded Smith's dismissal and policy changes, writing that the punishment exposed 'a significant disconnect between the RFU's stated commitment to zero tolerance of discrimination and the perception of how those principles are applied in practice'
- Warwickshire RFU announced Smith's resignation as county chair, stating 'we take issues of sexism and misogyny seriously,' while Smith's punishment had already been served before he sent a letter of apology to Alphonsi
- The RFU council, famously called '57 old farts' by then-England captain Will Carling in 1995, is being slimmed down to an advisory role under a governance review by CEO Bill Sweeney; council seats are unpaid but carry hospitality perks worth several hundred pounds per men's Test
Why it matters: The RFU's women in leadership collective publicly rebuked the union's own disciplinary process as performative, undermining the governing body's 'zero-tolerance' stance on discrimination at a time when the council itself is being restructured and its legitimacy already questioned.
