Kyle McCarren Musical Eulogy Debuts at Edinburgh Fringe
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- The Real Kyle McCarren is a new US musical by creator Andy Roninson, built as a "loving but warts-and-all" eulogy to his bandmate Kyle McCarren, who died unexpectedly at age 21.
- Roninson narrates and plays keys in a concert-style staging set in the days just after Kyle's death, weaving tributes from a "best friend" Liam, Kyle's "formidable mother," and his ex-girlfriend — each delivering a solo number in rock, soul or folk styles.
- Sean McVerry, who wrote the music and lyrics with Roninson, plays Kyle himself, appearing throughout the show and frequently ribbing Andy.
- Sarah Coffey's plaintive ballad as Kyle's ex is singled out as a standout solo, while songs are staged unconventionally — from Liam's eulogy to Andy and Kyle jamming as teens to a CD-skipping gag that triggers a recreation of a recording.
- The production is co-directed by Lonny Price and Matt Cowart; Roninson is a Jonathan Larson Grant recipient, and the reviewer compares the show's "off-kilter neuroses and wit" to those of Rent creator Jonathan Larson.
- The reviewer's chief critique: the show tells Kyle's story only in retrospect through others' reminiscences, leaving Kyle "elusive" and lacking a key incident or overarching plot — a gap fuller flashbacks could fill.
Why it matters: The Edinburgh Fringe is the world's largest performing-arts marketplace, and a Jonathan Larson Grant recipient debuting a polished, deeply personal rock musical about grief there signals a production with potential for off-Broadway or regional transfer — though the reviewer's verdict that the subject remains "elusive" flags a structural problem the creative team would need to solve before a wider run.
Ask SkimNews
