ChatGPT Gets WIRED's Product Picks Wrong
Get the Tech newsletter
Daily tech — startups, AI labs, chips, the launches that shape the next decade. Free.
- WIRED's Gear Reviews team tested ChatGPT's revamped product recommendation features and found the chatbot "regularly made mistakes or added random products" when asked what WIRED reviewers recommend across multiple categories.
- ChatGPT recommended the LG QNED Evo Mini-LED as WIRED's best TV overall, but the product isn't in WIRED's guide—WIRED's actual top pick is the TCL QM6K; ChatGPT later admitted it "took WIRED's actual top pick... and replaced it with a more generic 'similar category' Mini-LED option."
- ChatGPT listed Apple's AirPods Max 2 as WIRED's top headphone pick for Apple users, but WIRED hasn't tested them yet—the bot confused a news piece about the product's announcement for a hands-on review.
- ChatGPT insisted WIRED's top laptop pick was the MacBook Air (M4, 2025) when the current guide recommends the MacBook Air (M5, 2026); the bot's own self-diagnosis was that it "anchored the top pick to the M4 (that was outdated framing), then made up/guessed structure around 'M5 hierarchy' before verifying the actual WIRED page."
- Condé Nast, WIRED's parent company, has a business deal with OpenAI for WIRED links to appear in ChatGPT, yet none of ChatGPT's WIRED-based recommendations include affiliate links—a revenue model that already suffers as AI tools divert traffic away from publishers.
- Ryan Waniata, WIRED's headphone expert, said LLM "hallucinations make everything harder, especially for journalists. We're trying to do good work, and when it's not being appropriated or improperly attributed, it's being misquoted or incorrectly incorporated into search queries."
- OpenAI's announcement blog frames traditional "best of" lists as a nuisance—"jumping between tabs, reading the same 'best of' lists, and trying to piece together the right answer"—a stance WIRED's review calls a "lack of respect for the human labor of reviewers."
Why it matters: For shoppers trusting ChatGPT as a product-research shortcut, the bot's confident hallucinations risk sending them home with purchases they believe carry WIRED's endorsement but don't. For publishers, the errors compound an already painful traffic and revenue squeeze: AI tools that link to buying guides but misrepresent their recommendations capture the upside while eroding the source's affiliate economics.
