'Bad Counselors' Review: Stealth Christian Frat-Bro Comedy
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Bad Counselors is a faith-based comedy directed by Chris Dowling that follows fraternity bros Grayson (Matt Cornett) and Tyler (Ramon Reed), who are sentenced to community service at the Burning Bush Camp megachurch after drunken carousing crosses a line with local police officer Montgomery (Missi Pyle).
- Fathom Entertainment distributed the film in a limited theatrical run, with Variety noting VOD and youth church groups as the likely widest audience for a PG-13 comedy that goes 'pretty light on the Bible-bashing relative to others in its cinematic church.'
- Matt Cornett leads the cast as affable but obnoxious frat-bro Grayson, whose 'dudebro energy' Variety credits with balancing the character; the review flags that his crossover drawing power depends on whether the Prime series 'Every Year After' elevates his profile.
- Chris Klein plays supervising pastor Tom, Brec Bassinger his daughter Jenna (Grayson's love interest), Nathan Gamble the jealous youth pastor Dallas, and McKaley Miller the zealous volunteer Becky who recruits the two non-believers, with an uncredited 'American Pie' alum cameo noted in the review.
- The film's comic engine — Grayson bafflingly navigating Christian rituals while mentoring awkward camper Patrick (Brayden Gleave) — is undercut by its refusal to make Burning Bush look 'overly absurd,' resulting in little irony, limited conflict, and an interpretive-dance climax set to Christian rock that Variety says is where 'Bad Counselors has itself forsaken laughs entirely.'
- Variety explicitly invokes the 2004 satirical film 'Saved!' as the sharper, snarkier elder-millennial Christian-youth portrait this movie isn't, framing 'Bad Counselors' as intriguing evidence of faith-based cinema 'flirting, however briefly and gingerly, with danger.'
Why it matters: For faith-based distributors like Fathom Entertainment, 'Bad Counselors' represents an attempt to reach a younger, secular audience by borrowing the frat-comedy template — but Variety's verdict suggests the film satisfies neither crossover viewers nor those seeking the satirical bite of earlier faith-meets-frat entries like 'Saved!,' likely confining its audience to VOD and church youth groups.
