BCNY's 150-year model: belonging shields boys from crisis
SkimNews Take
The Boys' Club becoming an "unlikely" mental health model suggests community-rooted, intergenerational belonging fills protective gaps that specialized clinical services struggle to address for boys.
Get the Health newsletter
Daily health & science — research, biotech, public health, the studies worth knowing. Free.
- Boys' Club of New York, founded in 1876 by railroad tycoon E.H. Harriman, serves about 2,500 boys across three clubhouses — a reporter looking for boys in mental health crisis left empty-handed, finding instead a 'wholesome, optimistic' environment.
- NYU professor Niobe Way argues mental health problems are symptoms of a 'social health problem' — boys crave close friendships but experience a 'crisis of connection' around age 16, the same age when suicide and violence rates spike.
- BCNY's approach, called 'collective care,' draws from Indigenous traditions, mutual aid, the African concept of ubuntu, and feminist frameworks, centering on four core values stamped on the clubhouse stairs: competence, connection, confidence, and character.
- Johns Hopkins researcher Dominick Shattuck compares BCNY to Australia's Men's Sheds, a 1980s workshop program credited with reducing loneliness and suicide risk among men, calling the sheds 'basically like a Boys' Club for adult men.'
- Many BCNY staff are alumni who 'grew up' in the clubhouses, providing organic mentorship — boys are called 'members' (original joining fee was one penny in 1893, about 37 cents today), not charity recipients.
Why it matters: As boys face rising mental health and academic struggles nationwide, BCNY's 150-year-old model — alumni-staff mentorship, structured intergenerational bonding, and a 'member-not-charity' identity — offers a replicable framework for at-risk youth programs, paralleling Australia's Men's Sheds initiative. The club's unflashy formula of belonging challenges the assumption that crisis-scale problems require crisis-scale innovation.
