Boys' Club of NY has shielded 2,500 boys from mental health crisis
Get the Health newsletter
Daily health & science — research, biotech, public health, the studies worth knowing. Free.
- Boys' Club of New York serves roughly 2,500 members across three clubhouses (in Queens and the Bronx), founded by railroad tycoon E.H. Harriman in 1876 in a Lower East Side school basement — originally offering reading materials and boxing lessons, now recording studios, robotics, and swimming.
- NYU developmental psychologist Niobe Way, a BCNY adviser, found that boys and girls want equally close friendships but boys hit a 'crisis of connection' at age 16, suppressing emotional sharing at precisely the age when suicide and violence rates spike.
- BCNY's 'collective care' model draws on Indigenous traditions, mutual aid, ubuntu ('I am because we are'), and feminist frameworks emphasizing interdependence — with four core values stenciled on the Abbe Clubhouse stairs: competence, connection, confidence, character.
- Most BCNY staff are alumni who 'grew up' in the clubhouses, creating organic mentorship; CEO Stephen Tosh emphasizes the membership model, which dates to 1893 when the joining fee was one penny (37 cents today): 'You're not just a recipient, you're not just a charity case, you are a member.'
- Johns Hopkins researcher Dominick Shattuck compares BCNY to Australia's Men's Sheds, a 1980s program credited with reducing rural male suicide, where 'men talk shoulders to shoulders, not face to face' — calling the sheds 'basically a Boys' Club for adult men.'
Why it matters: Boys face rising rates of mental health challenges, academic struggles, and identity issues, but BCNY's 150-year-old, low-tech formula — friendship, intergenerational mentorship, and belonging — is held up by researchers as a model worth replicating, paralleled by Australia's Men's Sheds program credited with reducing rural male suicide risk.
