BBC Settles Defamation Case With PinkNews Founder — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- The BBC apologized "unreservedly for the defamatory allegations" made in its late-2024 documentary "PinkNews: Behind Closed Doors" and an accompanying article titled "PinkNews bosses accused of sexual misconduct," removing the article from its website as part of the settlement.
- Benjamin Cohen and Anthony James received a formal apology and compensation after a joint statement at the UK High Court called the allegations "serious, false, defamatory… and extremely harmful to the claimants' reputations."
- The original BBC reporting claimed to have spoken with 30 current and former PinkNews employees, some of whom alleged bullying, sexual misconduct, and that young female staff had been asked to act as surrogates for the couple.
- Cohen and James argued the BBC "reinforced one of the most damaging homophobic tropes: that gay men are sexual predators who pose a threat to others," calling the allegations ones that "should never have been broadcast."
- The defamatory coverage triggered additional investigations by CAFCASS ahead of a parental order hearing at the Family Court regarding the couple's son, who was born via surrogate.
- The BBC's counsel told the High Court the corporation "accepts everything" and "retracts and apologises unreservedly," while a BBC spokeswoman said the corporation "will not be issuing any further comment."
Why it matters: The settlement forces a rare full retraction by the BBC and exposes how its reporting didn't just damage reputations — it triggered CAFCASS scrutiny of Cohen and James' parental rights, putting a young family through additional court proceedings over claims the BBC now admits were defamatory. It also raises the stakes for the corporation's editorial standards when reporting on LGBTQ+ subjects.
Ask SkimNews
