FX's 'The Shards' Review: Murphy-Ellis Adaptation Never Coheres
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Igby Rigney stars as a fictionalized Bret Easton Ellis in 'The Shards,' anchoring the coming-of-age half as a closeted senior whose friend group fractures when a mysterious transfer student arrives, with critics calling his performance a strong point amid the show's broader failures.
- Homer Gere plays Robert Mallory, the enigmatic new student linked to a string of Beverly Hills teen murders, but the review finds him 'too ethereal to evoke fear' and faults scripts that refuse to define the character and direction that prioritizes camp over horror.
- Ryan Murphy's adaptation departs from Ellis's 600-page source novel in later episodes, expanding to 'thin, trivial perspectives' and introducing a new mystery in the finale, with the serial-killer arc growing increasingly tacked on as the season collapses.
- FX and Hulu will premiere 'The Shards' on Wednesday, August 5 at 9 p.m. ET, dropping two episodes, then two on August 12, one on August 19, two on August 26, and weekly installments through the nine-episode finale on September 9.
- Bret Easton Ellis and Ryan Murphy share so many sensibilities—gratuitous violence, heavy music cues, obscene wealth, disaffected teens—that the reviewer suggests their familiarity is itself the problem, leaving a production 'filled with potential… that has no idea what to do with it.'
- Kaia Gerber, Graham Campbell, Hayes Warner, Wes Bentley, and Evan Rachel Wood round out the principal cast, with Gerber's Susan framed as the love interest at the center of Bret's jealousy over the new kid.
- Cross-coverage consensus: Variety's parallel review echoes the same diagnosis, titled 'FX's Adaptation of Bret Easton Ellis' The Shards Can't Be Saved by a Strong Lead Performance,' independently arriving at the conclusion that Rigney's work can't rescue a show that fails to unify its dual genre ambitions.
Why it matters: For FX and Hulu, the launch of a nine-episode limited series from a prestige novelist and a high-profile showrunner represents a meaningful prestige-TV bet that multiple top critics have already judged as not cohereing—costing the platform a likely awards-season anchor built on Ellis's cult following and Murphy's promotional reach.
