Review: Ryan Murphy's "The Shards" Never Comes Together
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- "The Shards" premieres Wednesday, August 5 at 9 p.m. ET on FX and Hulu, with two episodes at launch, additional drops through August 26, and the ninth and final episode airing September 9
- Igby Rigney stars as Bret, the closeted senior whose narration roots the show, opposite Kaia Gerber as class president Susan, Graham Campbell as her jock boyfriend Thom, and Hayes Warner as Bret's beard Debbie
- Homer Gere plays Robert Mallory, the ethereal transfer student whose arrival coincides with teen murders in Beverly Hills — and whose creep factor, the review argues, is undercut by direction that underplays the terror
- The serial killer arc grows increasingly "tacked on" as the season progresses, with later episodes breaking from Ellis's 600-page source novel, expanding into thin perspectives, and culminating in a finale mystery the reviewer says no one cares to solve
- Ryan Murphy's direction is faulted for shooting horror beats for "campy laughs" rather than genuine dread, and for a Shakespeare motif in Episode 8 that the reviewer dismisses as a "desperate, lazy swing at profundity"
- The show works best in its coming-of-age half — Bret's sexuality, absent parents, and chosen family of privileged teens — sharing obvious DNA with Ellis's obsessions (wealth, disaffected youth, violence), a familiarity the reviewer calls the problem, not the appeal
Why it matters: For prestige-TV viewers tracking the Murphy-Ellis partnership, the review casts "The Shards" as a missed opportunity: a strong lead turn from Rigney and a compelling friend-group drama get buried under a serial-killer subplot and later-episode departures from the source novel, leaving a 9-episode season that visibly loses narrative interest.
Ask SkimNews
