Carragher unsurprised as Tuchel picks Chalobah over
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Tino Livramento was ruled out of the 2026 World Cup on the eve of England's opener against Croatia after sustaining a calf injury in training, forcing Thomas Tuchel into a late squad change
- Thomas Tuchel called up Chelsea defender Trevor Chalobah as Livramento's replacement despite Chalobah not being a like-for-like right-back, passing over Real Madrid's Trent Alexander-Arnold
- Jamie Carragher said the snub was unsurprising, arguing Tuchel is 'picking team harmony, togetherness and spirit over quality and talent' and views Alexander-Arnold's defensive 'deficiencies' more heavily than his attacking strengths
- Trent Alexander-Arnold was already a high-profile omission from Tuchel's original 26-man squad and has struggled to impress the German since moving to Real Madrid
- Harry Maguire publicly revealed his shock at his own squad omission, saying Tuchel FaceTimed him and that media reports of his exclusion leaked roughly 30 minutes before he was officially told
- Carragher suggested Maguire's outspoken public comments — and those of his family — may have counted against him when the late right-back slot opened up, with a centre-back like Chalobah seen as a more versatile emergency option than Maguire
- Carragher's preferred England XI for the Croatia opener features Jude Bellingham at #10 ahead of Morgan Rogers, Anthony Gordon on the left over Marcus Rashford, and Ezri Konsa partnering Marc Guehi in central defence, leaving out John Stones
Why it matters: The decision cements Tuchel's stated preference for tactical fit and squad cohesion over individual reputation, leaving two of English football's most marketable names — Alexander-Arnold and Maguire — outside the 26-man group. England now open the 2026 World Cup against Croatia with a squad built entirely on Tuchel's terms rather than public expectation, a stance Carragher says Tuchel has held consistently rather than improvised under pressure.
Ask SkimNews
