Prima Facie Review: Erivo's TIFF Film Loses Play's Fire — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Prima Facie premiered at the Toronto Film Festival and is currently seeking distribution
- Cynthia Erivo stars as Tessa, a rising criminal defense lawyer at the Old Bailey who is raped by a colleague and lover (Daniel Ings) and brings the case to trial expecting a likely acquittal
- Suzie Miller's 2019 award-winning one-woman play, originally made famous by Jodie Comer in London and New York, has been adapted by director Susanna White into an ensemble film
- Supporting cast includes Noma Dumezweni as Tessa's mother June, a cleaner, and Toheeb Jimoh as her brother Johnny, a construction worker — characters who anchor Tessa's scholarship-girl backstory
- The Guardian review criticizes the film for a three-year time jump that skips the emotional fallout, for White's flat staging, and for reducing the Olivier-winning play to what the reviewer calls "Law & Order blandness"
- Tessa's arc moves from defending sex crime cases (where she exploits cross-examination tactics) to sitting on the other side of the bar, confronting the system she once helped perpetuate
Why it matters: Prima Facie's reception at TIFF underscores the persistent difficulty of converting solo stage performance into ensemble cinema — a commercial calculation that adds cast members but, this reviewer argues, costs the play its fire. The split verdict matters for producers weighing whether prestige legal dramas tied to ongoing discourse on rape trial mechanics can survive the transition from stage to screen.
Ask SkimNews
