NY Fed Confirms K-Shaped Economy: Top Earners Drive Spending
SkimNews Take
When top-decile spending propels headline retail growth, the Fed's reliance on aggregate demand gauges risks either choking the economy's only active engine or leaving lagging segments further behind — a calibration problem that targeted wealth taxes now threaten to deepen.
Get the Finance newsletter
Daily finance — markets, central banks, M&A, the prints that move money. Free.
- New York Fed research confirms the K-shaped economy, finding that real retail spending growth since January 2023 has been overwhelmingly concentrated among households earning more than $125,000 annually.
- High-income households ($125k+) saw cumulative real spending growth of about 7.6% through March 2026, compared to roughly 3% for middle-income earners ($40k–$125k) and just over 1% for low-income households (under $40k).
- Wealth gains, not wages, explain the divide: the real net worth of the top 1% has climbed more than 25% since 2023 on surging financial assets, while the middle 40% of households has gained less than 10%.
- The divergence opened in 2023 after pandemic-era relief programs for lower- and middle-income households expired; before COVID, lower-income households actually outpaced the wealthy in spending growth.
- Low-income consumers have been squeezed by inflation running persistently above the national average, leaving them with little buffer against additional economic shocks.
- Recent data shows real spending has turned negative across all income groups, even as the gap between high- and low-income households persists — a fragility the NY Fed flagged as a key vulnerability.
- Pantheon Macroeconomics pushed back on the K-shaped framing, noting the wealthiest households have accounted for a roughly stable 40% share of total consumer spending for 25 years.
Why it matters: The U.S. economy's increasing reliance on a single income cohort creates fragility: if the top 1%'s 25%+ net worth gains — driven by financial assets — reverse in a market correction, retail spending could contract sharply across the board, hitting a low-income base already eroded by persistent above-average inflation.
