'A Common Story' Review: An Italian Marriage Collapses in Silence — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Anna Foglietta, an Italian actress turned director, debuts with "A Common Story," a relationship drama that the reviewer argues is distinct within Italian cinema for using silence and spatial distance rather than the caustic verbal assaults typical of the genre.
- Alba Rohrwacher plays Erika, a nearly 45-year-old supermarket cashier who crumbles after her daughter Irene leaves for college, having built her identity entirely around being useful — baking, cleaning, and caring for her mother Altea.
- The review frames Erika's collapse through a feminist lens: she is unable to name her depression because she has never had access to the analytical language of self-reflection, making terms like "mental health provider" effectively meaningless to her.
- Guido Caprino plays Mauro, a construction worker further destabilized when his father Marcello secretly sells the family business, leaving him unable to fulfill his role as the family's anchor in the wake of his own emasculation by his father's barbs.
- A pivotal scene finds Erika calling a telemarketer about a face cream advertised on an infomercial, only to hang up disillusioned when she cannot answer basic questions about herself — the reviewer reads this as her inability to construct a consumer-society identity to replace her lost domestic roles.
- Cinematographer Andrea Benjamin Manenti shoots with rare cuts within scenes and uses framing to build visual barriers, amplifying the charged spaces between the couple; the only moment their voices rise comes when Foglietta shifts from a distant exterior shot to a tight interior one.
- Reviewer declares both Rohrwacher and Caprino deliver career-best performances, communicating inner turmoil through eyes, body language, and the voids between words rather than dialogue.
Why it matters: For art-house and Italian cinema specifically, Foglietta's debut reframes the relationship-drama breakup not as a screaming match but as a quiet collapse between people who love each other and lack the language to say so — and it centers a woman whose depression goes unnamed precisely because she has no vocabulary for it, a demographic rarely portrayed on screen.
Ask SkimNews
