Rays and Shadows Draws 620k Viewers Amid Debate
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Rays and Shadows has drawn more than 620,000 moviegoers since its March 18 release, a notable box‑office performance for a three‑hour period film.
- Jean Dujardin portrays Jean Luchaire, a press baron who shifted from pacifist activism to high‑profile collaboration and was sentenced to death after WWII.
- Libération critic Luc Chessel called the film a “disheartening biopic” and “masterclass in historical gaslighting,” accusing director Xavier Giannoli of relativizing collaboration.
- Le Monde historian Bénédicte Vergez‑Chaignon denounced a fabricated scene of Luchaire’s arrest by Resistance fighters and warned the film forces unjustified audience sympathy.
- Le Figaro editorialist Eugénie Bastié praised the film for avoiding a black‑and‑white narrative and depicting the gradual slide from pacifism to collaboration.
- Xavier Giannoli told France Inter the film shows how antisemitism was weaponized, drawing a parallel with today’s radical left, and said he approached the subject as a filmmaker, not a historian.
- Three historians (Yves Pourcher, Barbara Lambauer, Cédric Méletta) co‑signed a Le Nouvel Obs op‑ed defending the film and dismissing criticism as an “unofficial Ideological Validation Commission.”
Why it matters: Gaumont’s box‑office gain of more than 620,000 viewers gives the studio a rare commercial win for a long‑form period drama, while the stark split among Le Monde, Libération, and Le Figaro determines whether the film will legitimize nuanced views of French collaboration or be dismissed as revisionist, influencing cultural narratives.
