Five Lessons From 1994 MLB Strike as CBA Expires
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- MLB shut down on Aug. 12, 1994, forcing the cancellation of that year's World Series on Sept. 14 — commissioner Bud Selig called it "terrible... horrible... terrible" — and another work stoppage now threatens 2027 games when the collective bargaining agreement expires Dec. 1
- Spring 1995's replacement-player experiment was a disaster: Tigers manager Sparky Anderson boycotted it entirely, Yankees manager Buck Showalter called it "the worst time of my career," and teams sent scouts to the Mexican League to fill rosters
- Tony Gwynn was hitting .394 when the strike began and never got his shot at .400; the Montreal Expos were 74-40 under Felipe Alou ("the best team in baseball") and were effectively dismantled, costing the franchise its future in Montreal
- The 1994 strike ended careers overnight — 57 players never played another game after August 1994, 19 played their final major league game the day the strike began, and Harold Reynolds was released by the Rockies the day before the 1995 season despite being in peak shape
- Player solidarity in 1994 was "unheard-of" per former MLBPA general counsel Gene Orza, with stars like Cal Ripken, Dave Winfield, Eddie Murray, Kirby Puckett, and Orel Hershiser fully behind the strike — but Orza's view is that modern players have social media platforms that make maintaining unity harder
- F.P. Santangelo of Triple-A Ottawa was the only one of roughly 200 minor leaguers in the Expos' camp to refuse to cross picket lines in 1995, and Alou kept his word by calling him up on Aug. 2, 1995
Why it matters: The 1994 strike offers a precise inventory of what a 2027 work stoppage could cost: Gwynn's .400 chase, the Expos' 74-40 roster that could have saved baseball in Montreal, Don Mattingly's likely Hall of Fame case, and 57 abruptly ended careers. With owners demanding a salary cap before the CBA expires Dec. 1 and no comparable emotional story (like Cal Ripken's streak) to heal the wound this time, owners and players have no soft landing if talks fail.
Ask SkimNews
