Oakley's Faithful 'Sense and Sensibility' Earns Strong Reviews — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Georgia Oakley directs a new "Sense and Sensibility" adaptation that the review describes as "oak-solid" and faithful rather than modernized, with a visual style likened to "Barry Lyndon" favoring natural light over streaming-friendly gloss
- Daisy Edgar-Jones plays Elinor Dashwood in what the review calls "a deeply felt performance," leveraging her restrained register with occasional bursts of emotion
- Esmé Creed-Miles (daughter of Samantha Morton) is singled out as "the most potent breakout" as Marianne, with a second-act emotional breakdown set to Roger Goula's string score
- George MacKay plays Edward Ferrars with "earthly sensuality," while Frank Dillane plays Willoughby as "wily and louche" — both men disappoint the Dashwoods in distinct ways
- The cast also includes Caitríona Balfe as the matriarch, Fiona Shaw as Mrs. Jennings, Stacy Martin as Fanny, and a cameo from Eliot Sumner (Sting's non-binary child) as Mr. Palmer
- Cinematographer Arnaud Potier grounds the film in "lived-in" period detail across Sussex and Devon locations, with the review noting occasional drabness is intentional rather than a flaw
- Focus Features opens the film in US theaters on Friday, October 16, and the review positions it as a contender to the Ang Lee 1995 "definitive" version
Why it matters: By hewing to classical period filmmaking instead of slick modernization, Oakley's take bets that a 21st-century audience will embrace a literary drama rooted in restraint and physical setting — and the critical verdict here suggests the gamble pays off in performances, particularly Creed-Miles's breakaway turn, that give Austen's social claustrophobia real bodily weight.
Ask SkimNews
