Olivia Rodrigo: You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So in Love review – who’s she singing about? Who cares when the songs are this good
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Olivia Rodrigo's third album 'You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So in Love' is a song-cycle tracing a relationship from first romance to bitter post-breakup recriminations, and the reviewer calls it 'spectacularly accomplished pop whoever it is about.'
- The album pivots sharply from the gleefully bratty pop-punk of Guts toward 80s new wave, with the reviewer citing the B-52s, New Order, and Devo as detectable touchstones.
- Robert Smith of the Cure duets with Rodrigo on 'What's Wrong With Me?' after a Glastonbury cameo, and the Cure's influence runs through 'Drop Dead' (a Just Like Heaven reference), 'The Cure' (set in a Cure-like late-80s logo), 'Maggots for Brains,' and 'U + Me = <3.'
- The lyrics are more nuanced and thoughtful than the 'screw-you recriminations' that made Rodrigo famous — 'Less' captures a dying relationship with the wince-inducing line: 'We tried to recreate our favourite date, but we didn't laugh much this time.'
- 'Expectations' showcases a funnier, more cutting post-breakup Rodrigo: 'I met him at a party, I think he was on drugs / He wasn't smart or funny, I convinced myself he was.'
- The release has drawn extensive press decoding for references to ex Louis Partridge, including a 1,200-word annotated lyrics essay and Indian outlet speculation about a reconciliation, which the reviewer argues misses the point of how good the songs actually are.
Why it matters: For an artist who broke through at 17 and whose debut was sold with a high-school prom concert film, this third album is a confident sonic and emotional pivot — 80s new wave, Cure-obsessed, and substantially less vindictive — that the reviewer says 'feels nothing forced or uncomfortable' and proves Rodrigo 'is in it for the long haul' well past today's gossip cycle.
