Writer Flags Centrifuge Slip in Hail Mary, DNA Myth
SkimNews Take
The prevalence of easily rectifiable scientific errors in blockbusters suggests a broader industry prioritization of narrative convenience and spectacle over factual accuracy, even when the latter would not impede storytelling.
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Project Hail Mary shows an unbalanced centrifuge when protagonist Ryland Grace places two plastic tubes next to each other, violating basic lab protocol.
- Ryland Grace is a molecular biologist character who, despite his expertise, makes the centrifuge mistake in the film.
- Jurassic Park premise that dinosaur DNA can be extracted from fossils is impossible because the oldest DNA recovered is only 2 million years old, while dinosaurs vanished 66 million years ago.
- Helen Pilcher is a science writer and author of Life Changing: How Humans are Altering Life on Earth and This Book May Cause Side Effects, and she argues that minor scientific slip‑ups irritate knowledgeable viewers more than larger fictional liberties.
- Millennium Falcon is cited as an example of a sci‑fi vehicle that breaks physics (faster‑than‑light travel, sound in vacuum) but is tolerated by audiences, contrasting with the writer’s intolerance for small lab errors.
Why it matters: Pilcher’s critique shows that even minor scientific slip‑ups can alienate detail‑savvy viewers and damage a film’s credibility, meaning filmmakers risk losing an audience segment that values accurate science while gaining little narrative advantage from such errors and may face heightened criticism from the scientific community.
Ask SkimNews
