Brendan Sorsby would've ranked behind Fernando Mendoza but ahead of everyone else in the 2026 NFL Draft class
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Brendan Sorsby would have been QB2 in the 2026 NFL Draft had he declared, trailing only Fernando Mendoza but ahead of every other quarterback in the class, per the author's scouting of league personnel and statistical grading.
- Sorsby finished first among 2026 quarterbacks in Alpha Rate, Deep Alpha, and pressure-to-sack percentage — but last in second-read grade, a split the author says defines his evaluation: elite traits paired with a notable processing gap.
- Fernando Mendoza earned QB1 not by dominating categories but by offering fewer evaluation questions; the gap between Mendoza and Sorsby was 'certainty, not talent,' with Mendoza graded as 'calm, poised, anticipatory, accurate' at Oregon, Ohio State, and Miami.
- Kayshon Boutte offers a precedent for looking past gambling baggage: the Patriots drafted him after a Louisiana State Police investigation revealed thousands of wagers at LSU (including on his own team), and he detailed losing roughly $90,000 in a Players' Tribune essay before becoming a trusted deep target for Drake Maye.
- The Rams took Simpson No. 13 overall with only 15 career starts — a case the author raises to show the league's appetite for developmental quarterbacks, though Simpson's flaws were mechanical rather than off-field.
- The supplemental draft forces teams to decide now on a player scouts believed could have been a first-round pick in January, eliminating the extra year of tape-gathering and background investigation a regular draft cycle would allow.
Why it matters: Sorsby's evaluation forces NFL teams to choose between elite on-field production — first in Alpha Rate, Deep Alpha, and pressure-to-sack rate — and unresolved character concerns tied to gambling, with the supplemental draft's compressed timeline eliminating any option to wait for more information. Boutte's Patriots trajectory shows one organization already weighed similar baggage and found the talent worth it; the question is whether a franchise will hand the same player the keys to the entire operation.
