Gap, American Eagle Stocks Crushed—But Not by the Economy
Get the Finance newsletter
Daily finance — markets, central banks, M&A, the prints that move money. Free.
- Gap shares tumbled 15.4% Friday while American Eagle Outfitters slid 11.8% after both retailers reported earnings, yet executives at each company insisted the U.S. economy and consumer remain on solid footing
- Gap CFO Katrina O'Connell told analysts the consumer "remains resilient" and the company's outlook does not assume any meaningful shift, while flagging that Gap is watching whether rivals reinvest this year's tariff upside into pricing actions
- American Eagle CEO Jay Schottenstein declared the U.S. economy "very strong" and said it is "only going to get better," expressing optimism that gas prices will settle and "current affairs will come to some type of finish"
- Gap CEO Richard Dickson blamed the Old Navy miss on women's dresses, saying bluntly that the company "have not had the right fashion and value equation for that category" and insisting "we are not seeing this as a consumer issue"
- Athleta, Gap's athletics brand, posted an 11% same-store sales decline, and Gap cut its full-year revenue growth forecast to 1%–2% — down 1 percentage point from its prior guidance
- American Eagle attributed its softness to "softer trends in women's bottoms, including denim, along with pressure on seasonal categories during a colder spring," per Schottenstein
Why it matters: Gap and American Eagle explicitly rejected the tariff-driven slowdown narrative even as Gap trimmed its full-year revenue growth guide by a full percentage point and Athleta posted an 11% same-store sales drop, putting the blame squarely on company-specific fashion and merchandising stumbles — a framing that, if validated by peers in upcoming earnings, could insulate the broader retail sector from recession fears while spotlighting execution risk at Gap's portfolio of brands.
Ask SkimNews
