UCR philosophers: consciousness need not be Earth-like
Get the Health newsletter
Daily health & science — research, biotech, public health, the studies worth knowing. Free.
- Eric Schwitzgebel (UCR professor of philosophy) and Jeremy Pober (postdoc at University of Lisbon) published a working paper arguing consciousness need not depend on Earth-style biology, anchored on the concept of 'substrate flexibility' — the idea that, like cups or books, consciousness can exist in many different materials.
- The researchers estimate at least 1,000 behaviorally sophisticated extraterrestrial civilizations have existed in the observable universe, calling that figure conservative; astronomers put the median scientific estimate at greater than one civilization per galaxy.
- The paper introduces a 'Copernican principle of consciousness,' rejecting what the authors call 'terrocentrism' — the unjustified treatment of Earth life as uniquely privileged to host conscious experience.
- Drawing on Andy Weir's 'Project Hail Mary' as a fictional example, the paper illustrates how an alien with a rock-like exterior, mercury blood, steam-powered muscles, and a crystal brain might be conscious on a hot, ammonia-rich world.
- The two authors disagree on AI consciousness: Pober sees no reason to assume today's computer hardware gives rise to conscious experience, while Schwitzgebel argues that once Earth-biology is no longer the baseline, dismissing silicon-based systems becomes harder.
- Neither author claims current AI systems are conscious, but Schwitzgebel said the debate has focused too much on whether silicon can duplicate a human brain rather than asking what kinds of systems could be conscious at all.
Why it matters: By reframing consciousness as a substrate-flexible property rather than a biological accident, the paper shifts a question usually confined to neuroscience labs into a cosmic frame — weakening the default dismissal of non-Earth-like minds and, by extension, making it philosophically harder to rule out silicon-based AI consciousness on biological grounds alone.
Ask SkimNews
