CDC Withholds Pennsylvania Measles Deaths From Dashboard — SkimNews
Get the Health newsletter
Daily health & science — research, biotech, public health, the studies worth knowing. Free.
- Debra Houry and Demetre Daskalakis, the CDC's former chief medical officer and former director of the National Center for Immunization and Respiratory Diseases, resigned in protest last summer over political interference and scientific integrity concerns, and are now publicly sounding the alarm.
- CDC Director Erica Schwartz withheld Pennsylvania's two reported measles deaths from the national dashboard after the state followed standard notification protocols, raising the question of whether the agency now applies different standards based on a state's political leadership.
- The Pennsylvania outbreak, centered in Lancaster, has infected more than 400 people and hospitalized 83, with children at risk of pneumonia, encephalitis, immune-memory loss, and a rare fatal neurological disorder that can appear years later.
- HHS leadership pushed unproven treatments during the response — appearing on national television eating beef-tallow french fries while falsely claiming the MMR vaccine causes more deaths than measles, and promoting vitamin A, inhaled steroids, and antibiotics as measles cures.
- When HHS asked CDC to revise clinician guidance to include those unproven treatments, CDC scientists declined because the interventions lacked "gold-standard" evidence, while reports surfaced of vitamin A toxicity from unsupervised use.
- By contrast, when Texas reported the nation's first measles deaths in a decade in 2025, state officials followed the same protocol without political interference and CDC provided financial support, vaccines, and on-the-ground personnel.
- Groups such as Children's Health Defense publicly questioned whether measles caused the Texas children's deaths, blaming the treating hospital instead of the virus, and exploited grieving families to spread doubt about vaccination.
- The standard case-definition process — built through the Council of State and Territorial Epidemiologists and CDC epidemiologists — is the boring but essential machinery that lets states and the federal government trust each other's numbers.
Why it matters: With kindergarten vaccination rates falling and more than 400 infected in a single Pennsylvania outbreak, the CDC's perceived politicization of mortality data directly threatens the state-federal trust that outbreak response depends on; if states cannot rely on consistent case definitions, response coordination, lab support, and contact tracing all degrade as measles complications become more common.
Ask SkimNews
