Acaster confesses; The Celebrity Traitors loses edge — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- James Acaster confessed at the 29 October penultimate round table that he had murdered Ross Kemp and revealed his Traitor identity after Michael Sheen grilled him; the source says such a full confession had never happened on the show and took some wind out of its sails.
- The Celebrity Traitors has broken The Traitors’ sky-high ratings records, but the series has felt underwhelming and tentative, lacking a certain spark and the “OMG!” impact associated with the show.
- Richard E Grant told Joe Lycett in episode one that he was a Traitor and was quickly banished, depriving viewers of turret scheming with Maya Jama and setting in motion the recruitment chain behind most later Traitors.
- The Celebrity Traitors had most Traitors selected by the Traitors themselves rather than producers; recruitment every few episodes rendered many earlier game events null and void, which the source says eroded narrative cohesion.
- Hannah Fry did not appear fully comfortable as a Traitor, and Acaster openly did not want the role; the show is more fun, the source argues, when celebrities such as Alan Carr in the 2025 series gleefully plot in the shadows.
- The Traitors often has its biggest characters murdered or banished first because they threaten either the Traitors or the Faithful; the celebrity version intensifies audience disappointment because viewers already know the players.
- James Acaster drew social-media anger and accusations of mocking the game after his confession; the author calls the backlash misplaced frustration over missing “OMG!” moments, with even the murder in plain sight feeling underwhelming.
Why it matters: Richard E Grant’s episode-one banishment triggered the recruitment chain that produced most Traitors, including James Acaster and Hannah Fry, who appeared reluctant or uncomfortable. With recruits arriving every few episodes and many earlier events nullified, the show lost narrative cohesion and the conflict that made the format compelling.
Ask SkimNews
