Opinion: U.S., U.K. Health Systems Share a Fatal Flaw
Get the Health newsletter
Daily health & science — research, biotech, public health, the studies worth knowing. Free.
- Kyle Vanelli, policy and data analyst at Local Trust, argues in an opinion piece that both the U.S. and U.K. health systems share a 'biomedical mandate' that privileges hospital-based clinical care over the relational, community-based support that keeps people healthy.
- NHS spending on hospitals rose from 47% of its budget in 2006 to 58% in 2022, despite two decades of prevention-focused policy plans promising a 'left shift' toward community-based care, according to the article.
- The U.S. fee-for-service model rewards clinical activity over prevention and creates commercial incentives that benefit hospitals, insurers, pharmaceutical companies, and manufacturers from a system organized around diagnosis and treatment.
- The Big Local program has given £1 million (~$1.3M) each to 150 communities across England since 2012, funded through the National Lottery, allowing residents to invest in locally chosen priorities like healthy food donations, safe play spaces, and social events.
- Big Local has inspired a £5 billion U.K. government investment in neighborhood regeneration, while the U.S. Accountable Health Communities program showed that connecting Medicaid patients to community-based support reduced their demand for health care services.
- Former Surgeon General Vivek Murthy has warned of an 'epidemic of loneliness' driven by declining social connectedness, as deaths of despair and demand for mental health services have soared in both countries alongside stagnating U.S. life expectancy.
- Community examples cited include Podsmead Big Local in Gloucester restoring a deprived estate through food aid and events, Ewanrigg's chair yoga sessions for older residents, and Bedford residents organizing diabetes support and therapeutic gardening groups that were extended by a local GP practice.
Why it matters: Vanelli's argument lands as both countries face rising costs, aging populations, and stagnating life expectancy — yet NHS hospital spending grew from 47% to 58% of its budget between 2006 and 2022. The Big Local program's 150 communities and £5 billion government follow-on show a tested, scalable alternative to the clinical-default model if policymakers choose to fund social infrastructure rather than more hospital capacity.
Ask SkimNews
