Zendaya's Iranian Gold Earrings Spark Provenance Debate
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Zendaya wore earrings at a London photocall for The Odyssey that gallery Barron London attributes to the Ziwiye hoard, gold medallion plaques discovered in northwest Iran in the late 1940s and dated to the 1st millennium BC.
- Barron London acquired the plaques from London jeweller Glenn Spiro, who mounted them with diamonds in yellow gold, and described the loan as a celebration of "ancient Persian artistry," the source notes.
- Romina Frohar, founder of the Forensic Archive of Iran, launched a petition demanding Barron London publish complete provenance, reveal legality checks, permit examination of the objects, and suspend sale.
- Frohar argued that "cultural appreciation cannot substitute for provenance transparency" and that legal possession alone does not extinguish the cultural claims of the people whose history the object embodies.
- Dr Christos Tsirogiannis of the Swiss Federal Office of Culture said he was "extremely surprised, negatively surprised" that no one on Zendaya's team flagged the issue, and estimated that about 90% of antiquities on the market are proved to be illicit or lacking provenance.
- Simon Mackenzie of Victoria University of Wellington noted that most source countries including Iran now have state ownership laws making looting essentially theft, though legal arguments can hinge on when such rules applied.
- Tsirogiannis pointed out the final irony: Zendaya's jewellery put the spotlight on Iran while promoting a film that had nothing to do with ancient Persia.
- The antiquities trade extends beyond Mayfair, with online dealers listing items from an Egyptian mummy mask (664–332 BC) to Hellenistic gold earrings from £450, and Christie's selling a 3,000-year-old Assyrian relief for nearly $31m in 2018.
Why it matters: The petition forces Barron London to publicly defend the legal export trail of the Ziwiye plaques, and a forced disclosure could expose whether the items left Iran before or after its state ownership laws applied — a determination that could open broader scrutiny of Mayfair's antiquities trade, where Tsirogiannis estimates 90% of stock may be illicit or undocumented.
