Conflicting Rulings Keep Anthropic in Supply-Chain Risk Limbo
Get the Tech newsletter
Daily tech — startups, AI labs, chips, the launches that shape the next decade. Free.
- Anthropic has not satisfied the requirements to lift its supply-chain-risk designation, a Washington, DC, appeals court ruled, emphasizing military readiness amid an ongoing conflict.
- A San Francisco judge ordered the Pentagon to remove the supply-chain risk label last week, finding the Department of Defense likely acted in bad faith due to frustration with Anthropic’s proposed AI use limits.
- The Trump administration restored federal access to Anthropic’s AI tools following the San Francisco ruling, but the DC appeals court’s stay now allows the risk designation to remain in place.
- Acting Attorney General Todd Blanche called the DC Circuit’s decision a 'resounding victory for military readiness,' asserting that control over AI use in defense systems belongs to the Commander-in-Chief, not tech companies.
- Anthropic claims it lost business due to the designation, arguing the Pentagon is punishing it for publicly questioning the reliability of its AI in lethal autonomous operations.
- The DC Circuit panel acknowledged Anthropic could suffer financial harm but refused to override military judgment, citing the risk of 'substantial judicial imposition on military operations.'
Why it matters: Anthropic faces prolonged exclusion from federal contracts despite a lower court finding government misconduct, because higher courts defer to national security claims. This creates a precedent where military authority can override corporate rights even amid allegations of executive overreach, affecting tech firms’ willingness to challenge defense policies.
