Sutton vs Copilot: AI Tops BBC Predictions League
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Microsoft Copilot finished top of the BBC Sport predictions league on its first attempt last season, prompting Sutton to joke the score is 'Machines 1-0 Humans' and ask whether he was 'hacked' after losing the title on the final day
- Chris Sutton is again making predictions for all 380 Premier League games this season against Copilot, BBC readers and rotating guests, with correct results worth 10 points and exact scores worth 40
- Liam Fray, frontman of Manchester band Courteeners, is Sutton's guest for the opening round and is promoting their forthcoming 'best of' compilation 'God Bless The Band', out 28 August
- Fray, a Manchester United fan, said he wanted Michael Carrick given the job 'straight away' after Ruben Amorim's January sacking, praising his visible connection with fans and the club
- All three predictors — Sutton, Fray and Copilot — agreed on Arsenal beating Coventry 3-0 at the Emirates on Friday night, but split on the Saturday Hull vs Manchester United fixture, where Fray predicted 0-3, AI predicted 1-3 and Sutton predicted 1-2
- The AI predictions are generated by simply asking Microsoft Copilot Chat to 'predict this weekend's Premier League results', with no model shown in the article
Why it matters: Copilot winning the BBC league in its first attempt flips the human-vs-machine framing — the humans are now the defending underdogs, and Sutton's hacking joke shows how thin the margin was. With 380 matches to call across the season, the format gives the BBC a recurring hook that fuses Premier League storylines (Fray's United optimism under Carrick) with a lighthearted test of generative AI forecasting accuracy.
Ask SkimNews
