Carrie Finale Deviates From Book To Kill Lillard & Midthunder — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Matthew Lillard and Amber Midthunder star as Principal Grayle and Miss Desjardin in Prime Video's eight-episode Carrie, Mike Flanagan's adaptation of Stephen King's 1974 debut novel, now streaming in full.
- Both characters die in the fiery finale 'AP Physics,' deviating from the book where they survive; Lillard said their deaths signify how 'catastrophic' Carrie's loss of control becomes, arguing she 'would have probably saved these two characters' if still in command.
- Midthunder called their fate 'part of the tragedy,' noting that seeing consistently good characters fall — alongside Tommy (Joel Oulette) — adds to Carrie's guilt, even as 'nobody is perfect' in the show's morally gray world.
- Principal Grayle is a new character replacing the previously Mr. Morton; Lillard originated the role as the 'calm in the storm' and 'moral compass,' with Flanagan directing him toward a 'grounded and resolute, but simple' performance.
- Lillard praised Flanagan's pre-production process: all eight scripts were written before day one, the cast had a month of rehearsal, and Flanagan could tell actors exactly how each scene would be shot, giving them 'freedom within form.'
- Midthunder fleshed out Miss Desjardin as a three-dimensional figure — new to town, lonely, and drawn into a relationship with Mr. Peist (Rahul Kohli) born from 'comfort and ease of circumstance,' a storyline absent from prior adaptations.
- Both actors are reuniting with Flanagan on 'Rot,' directed by Alex Magistro, whom Lillard described as 'Mike's right-hand woman'; Midthunder hinted her role there is 'very different' and 'a little scary.'
Why it matters: Flanagan is reshaping King's iconic story by killing characters who functioned as moral centers and introducing Principal Grayle as a replacement for the previously male Mr. Morton — choices that deepen the finale's tragedy and signal a willingness to depart from prior adaptations (including the 1976 De Palma film and 2013 remake) where these figures survived.
Ask SkimNews
