Neuroscientist: Concerts Restore Collective Effervescence
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Bala Subramaniam, a Harvard Medical School professor of anesthesiology, recounts that attending a Nick Jonas concert three years ago reintroduced him to Émile Durkheim's 19th-century concept of 'collective effervescence' — the dissolution of individual self-concern into communal intensity
- Subramaniam's own research on the Shambavi Mahamudra Kriya meditation practice found it reduces activity in the brain's default mode network (DMN), the circuit responsible for planning, daydreaming and self-talk — a pattern he says also occurs at concerts
- The article cites neuroimaging evidence suggesting people with depression struggle to switch out of DMN-heavy rumination mode, positioning collective experiences as a 'circuit breaker' for overactive self-referential thought
- Subramaniam cites synchrony research showing that shared dancing with 'out-group members' of different age groups increases real-life cooperation — the mechanism he uses to distinguish concerts from partisan sports or religious gatherings
- Former US Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy is quoted warning that loneliness carries health risks comparable to smoking, which Subramaniam uses to argue dancefloors deserve the same institutional status as libraries or museums
- The piece notes the nightlife industry adage 'Phones killed the dancefloor,' pointing to smartphone surveillance and TikTok anxiety as eroding the loss-of-self that collective effervescence requires
- Sadhguru, Subramaniam's meditation teacher, appeared on stage at Romania's 470,000-capacity Untold electronic music festival to call for greater collective consciousness — a precedent Subramaniam invokes for treating ecstatic dancing as enriching rather than hedonistic
Why it matters: Subramaniam is making a public-health argument: venues producing collective belonging are currently classified as nightlife or entertainment, but if loneliness carries smoking-equivalent health risks and synchronized dancing measurably boosts cross-group cooperation, then policy and funding frameworks that treat dancefloors as frivolous may be misallocating public health resources at a moment when a documented loneliness epidemic is worsening.
Ask SkimNews
