Would the USMNT actually win the World Cup if the best U.S. athletes played soccer?
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Lionel Messi at 5'7" and 148 pounds is the proof case — his low center of gravity, short-area quickness, and vision are exactly the traits the viral 'NFL/NBA all-stars' roster would lack, since players like Justin Jefferson (6'1", 195 lbs) and Ja'Marr Chase (205 lbs) don't fit that profile and would need to slim down to even play winger.
- ESPN FC's top 100 splits positions sharply: goalkeepers, center backs, and center forwards average 6'2" and 183+ pounds, while fullbacks, all midfielders, and wingers average 5'11" and just over 160 pounds — meaning the 190+-pound American athlete body has almost no natural landing spot except striker or center back.
- Across three seasons in the big five European leagues, only 1 of 33 players to record 10+ assists stood 6'2" or taller — Cristiano Ronaldo at exactly 6'2" — and players 5'7" or shorter (27) outnumbered 6'2"+ creators (15) nearly 2-to-1 in a broader 267-player chance-creation sample.
- Over 15 seasons, players 6'2" or taller accounted for roughly 22% of minutes but only about 12% of assists, chances created, and successful dribbles — confirming the article's claim that teams don't build through tall creators.
- Among the ESPN FC top 100 players outside the three 'big' positions, only Scott McTominay (6'4", 192 lbs) is listed at 190 pounds or more, leaving no realistic winger, midfielder, or fullback template for an NFL-caliber body.
- The US men's flag football team, whose 10 of 12 players are 5'11" or shorter (captain Darrell Doucette at 5'7"), beat teams of current and former NFL stars — including Saquon Barkley, Jalen Hurts, Tom Brady, Patrick Peterson, Luke Kuechly, and DeVonta Smith — by a combined 106-44 across three games.
- Norway had the heaviest, tallest minute-weighted squad at the 2026 World Cup (6'3", 182 lbs average), and other physically large teams — Bosnia, the Netherlands, Germany — crashed out early, while Argentina fielded the shortest team in the tournament and Spain ranked 30th in height and 26th in weight.
Why it matters: The analysis undercuts the populist assumption that raw American athletic depth could translate to instant World Cup contention, grounding that rebuttal in concrete positional data: only 1 of 33 top assist-getters in Europe's big five leagues stood 6'2" or taller, and the flag football exhibition result (106-44) demonstrates that even within tackle football's closest cousin, superior size and athleticism lose to skill specific to the game. The bottleneck for US Soccer isn't talent-pool size — it's that the 5'7"-to-5'11" creator archetype almost never emerges from NFL or NBA pipelines.
