Netflix YA Series 'Crew Girl' Draws Tepid Review — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- "Crew Girl" — Netflix YA series created by Vivian Lin follows 16-year-old Teagan Tao (Miku Martineau), whose father David (Byron Lawson), a wealthy hotelier, flees the FBI after stealing from clients, forcing Teagan and her mother Ella (Jessica Paré) to relocate from LA to fictional Eagle's Cove, Massachusetts.
- Teagan — bulldozes her way onto Easton Prep's all-boys crew team as coxswain after learning girls aren't permitted to row, and must win over a roster the reviewer describes as 'redpill-coded frat bros' to earn the school a girls' team.
- The review — groups 'Crew Girl' with other recent YA dramas including Netflix's 'My Life With the Walter Boys' and Prime Video's 'The Runarounds,' accusing all three of lacking 'real heart, soul or texture' and recycling 'worn-down tropes.'
- Miku Martineau's casting — as a Japanese Canadian lead is singled out as 'an important marker of representation in a genre that rarely puts Black people and people of color in the driver's seat.'
- The mother-daughter bond — between Teagan and Ella is highlighted as a redeeming quality, built on safety and 'an appropriate amount of transparency' amid a cast of adults the reviewer calls 'terrible parents who parentify their kids.'
- The broader critique — argues that until creators capture the specificity of Gen Z and Gen Alpha navigating a 'hyper-digital world' and 'post-pandemic anxiety,' YA audiences will 'be doomed to watch regurgitated stories.'
- Teagan's romantic sparks — with crewmates Cam (Kyle Clark) and Josh (Sam Braun) provide 'much-needed intrigue,' but the reviewer says the chemistry isn't enough to offset the show's contrived plot points.
Why it matters: The reviewer's critique extends well past 'Crew Girl' to argue that the entire YA drama genre is recycling prep-school and sports-team tropes while Gen Z and Gen Alpha navigate what the source calls 'a hyper-digital world' and 'post-pandemic anxiety.' With Netflix continuing to greenlight formulaic eight-episode teen series, the gap between what young audiences actually live and what they see scripted on screen keeps widening.
Ask SkimNews
