Forever Home TV Adaptation Brutally Panned — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Channel 5 aired "Forever Home," a six-part thriller adapted from Graham Norton's bestselling novel, in which Carol (Amy Nuttall) discovers a corpse defrosting in a faulty cellar freezer — revealed to be the body of her partner Robert's first wife.
- Douglas Henshall stars as Robert, a man in the early stages of dementia whose partner Carol is determined to prove innocent; the reviewer calls Henshall "far better than he needs to be."
- The cast also features Denise Welch as Robert's theatrical mother-in-law Moira, Lewis Cope as his son Kaden, Jenny Walser as daughter Sally, and James Baxter in a saucy subplot as adulterous spanner Patrick.
- The reviewer lumps "Forever Home" into Channel 5's "Indistinguishable Domestic Thriller Processing Complex," grouping it with "Number One Fan," "For Her Sins," "The Fortune" and "The Game" as mechanically formulaic.
- The show's attempt to undercut grim subject matter — dismemberment, stalking — with winking humour and a comedic string motif "does not work," according to the review, which calls the result "a drunken soap" without the earnestness or depth to sustain it.
- The only tonal restraint comes in scenes dealing with Robert's dementia, which are scored with a sad piano rather than the show's usual comedic cues.
Why it matters: For Channel 5, the reviewer's placement of "Forever Home" squarely inside its "Indistinguishable Domestic Thriller Processing Complex" underscores the brand risk of grafting a bestselling Norton novel onto the network's familiar template — Henshall's performance emerges as the only quality marker cited.
Ask SkimNews
