How books really become bestsellers — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Book covers are focus-grouped with supermarket buyers like Tesco and Waterstones, who have "tremendous clout" to demand changes, according to designer Jamie Keenan; the shift toward bold, thumbnail-friendly designs has backfired as saturated "jewel tones" make titles blend together on shelves.
- Bestseller charts are partly bought: "those top 10s are earned positions and they are very much not earned positions. They're paid for," an experienced publicist told the Guardian; TG Jones (formerly WH Smith) similarly charged publishers for chart space, per a 2022 BBC report, and Waterstones charged for display tables before James Daunt took over.
- Copywriters use Christopher Booker's "Seven Basic Plots" framework and tailor blurbs to the "F-shape" reading pattern, packaging books to fit trends like cosy crime — even when the writing doesn't match, according to a commercial publisher's copywriter who says "publishers are lemmings."
- Independent booksellers drive sales through focused window displays — three of four at Daunt Books' Marylebone branch are dedicated to a single title — and hand-selling, where one staff recommendation can reach "30, 40 people" in the shop, manager Brett Wolstencroft said.
- Goldsboro Books runs four subscription "book clubs" — including a fantasy club with 2,000 members and a debut fiction club with nearly 500 — and founder David Headley says being selected for one "can get you into the top 10 bestsellers."
- Author endorsements on covers are frequently favors traded through personal networks, with Stephen King and Tony Parsons named as near-ubiquitous blurbers; copywriter Louise Willder says audiences are "mistrustful" of the quotes.
Why it matters: Best-seller charts that consumers, booksellers, and media use to gauge "what's popular" are partially paid placements — meaning chart-driven visibility isn't purely organic. Readers are steered toward titles whose publishers paid supermarkets for top-10 space, potentially sidelining better or more diverse books without that marketing budget. The cosy-crime and romantasy boom, meanwhile, is described as a herd-driven packaging trend rather than a pure shift in reader taste.
Ask SkimNews
