17 Active NFL Players Are Already Hall of Fame Locks
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Bill Barnwell sorted active players into five tiers — "in," "on the cusp," "keep it up," "work to do," and "missing out" — with 17 players already at the "in" level where retirement today wouldn't derail their Canton case
- For the Los Angeles Rams, Myles Garrett, Davante Adams, and Matthew Stafford all qualify as locks; Stafford sits in the top seven for career passing yards and touchdowns and has both an MVP and a Super Bowl victory
- The San Francisco 49ers have three locks in Mike Evans, Trent Williams, and Christian McCaffrey, while George Kittle and Fred Warner are on the cusp despite both suffering serious Achilles/leg injuries last postseason
- Seattle's defending Super Bowl champions have no player above the "work to do" tier — a product of their uniquely young roster, with Jaxon Smith-Njigba (Offensive Player of the Year) and Devon Witherspoon (just the 10th DB in league history to start his career with three Pro Bowls) as the top candidates
- Aaron Rodgers and Derrick Henry anchor the veteran-locks group, while Justin Jefferson and Pat Surtain II represent prime-age candidates; Barnwell uses the 2002 season — which produced 54 Hall of Famers among 1,839 players (about 3%) — as a baseline benchmark
- Kyle Juszczyk's 10th consecutive Pro Bowl nod makes him a live test of the rule that every eligible player with 10+ Pro Bowls makes the Hall; Barnwell notes the 49ers cut him to save $500,000 before re-signing him and flags fullbacks as a historically under-honored position
Why it matters: By grounding projections in historical comparables rather than opinion, Barnwell gives fans a reproducible framework for tracking legacy-defining careers as they happen — and the 17-player "lock" count means Canton debates for stars like Stafford and Garrett aren't theoretical, they're queueing up the moment each retires.
