Every Active NFL Player With a Realistic Hall of Fame Case
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Bill Barnwell published an all-32 team breakdown identifying active NFL players with Hall of Fame trajectories, using the 2002 season as a benchmark where 55 of the 1,839 players who appeared in a game (about 3%) are now enshrined.
- Matthew Stafford, Davante Adams, and Myles Garrett are the only three players in the NFC West listed as locks; Stafford reached the top seven in career passing yards and touchdowns and won MVP and a Super Bowl.
- Kyle Juszczyk just earned his 10th consecutive Pro Bowl nod, making him a test case for the historical pattern that every eligible player with at least 10 Pro Bowls makes the Hall, though Barnwell notes fullbacks get fewer snaps and recognition.
- George Kittle and Fred Warner sit on the cusp for the 49ers, with Kittle's seven Pro Bowls and four 1,000-yard seasons at a position Barnwell says can be underappreciated by voters.
- Nick Bosa has a Defensive Player of the Year award but lost two of his seven pro seasons to ACL tears, putting him in the 'work to do' category.
- Jaxon Smith-Njigba (Offensive Player of the Year) and Devon Witherspoon (Pro Bowl in each of his first three seasons, the 10th defensive back ever to do so) are the Seahawks' top candidates, though Seattle has no players in the 'in' or 'on the cusp' tiers.
- Budda Baker has eight Pro Bowls in nine seasons on mostly losing Cardinals teams and needs two more to hit the 10-Pro Bowl threshold that has historically guaranteed enshrinement.
Why it matters: Voters have inducted every eligible player with 10+ Pro Bowls, so Juszczyk's 10th nod and Baker's chase of two more become live experiments in that historical rule. With Stafford, Adams, and Garrett already locked in, the Rams' free-agent decisions on pending DL contributors like Kobie Turner and Byron Young will shape whether the roster can sustain multiple Hall trajectories simultaneously.
Ask SkimNews
