From playoff QBs to potential stars we're stacking the 40 most crucial players
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Keelon Russell tops the list as Alabama's likely new starter after redshirting behind Ty Simpson, tasked with an unproven skill corps and brand-new offensive line — and has yet to officially win the job.
- Josh Hoover inherits the Indiana offense after Fernando Mendoza's one-year Heisman, national title, and No. 1 pick trifecta, bringing 9,629 career passing yards and 19 wins but needing to cut interceptions.
- Darian Mensah moves from ACC champion Duke to Miami with receivers Cooper Barkate and Malachi Toney, after Carson Beck led the Hurricanes within 47 yards of the national title.
- Arch Manning led the nation in Total QBR from November onward in 2025 (11 TDs, 1 INT) and now faces the test of a thinner but higher-upside Texas supporting cast.
- Dante Moore returned to Oregon despite projecting as a top-two NFL draft pick, but averaged just 5.9 yards per dropback with a 36% success rate and a 4-to-5 TD-to-INT ratio against SP+ top-10 defenses.
- Ryan Coleman-Williams posted a 13.0% drop rate at Alabama in 2025 — worst among highly targeted receivers — making his emergence the single biggest boost available to Russell.
- Demond Williams Jr. sparked Washington's turnaround from 6-7 to 9-4 but was dismal against three top-20 defenses (4.5 yards/dropback, 9.0 points per game), with the Huskies' fate now tied to season-ending games against Indiana and Oregon.
Why it matters: The 2026 college football narrative flips from 2025's parade of first-time starters — when 13 of 21 top title contenders had new QBs — to a veterans' league where established passers like Arch Manning and Dante Moore must now validate their potential against elite defenses rather than simply survive. Several contenders (Alabama, Indiana, Miami) face direct QB-successor pressure after trophy-winning predecessors, while Washington and Tennessee carry the burden of proving their surprise seasons weren't flukes.
