2027 NFL Draft: It's early, but Arch Manning hasn't looked like a first-rounder, let alone a No. 1 pick — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Arch Manning is averaging 6.8 yards per attempt through three 2026 games (vs. Texas State, Ohio State, UTSA), matching only 2019 No. 6 pick Daniel Jones among the 24 first-round QBs from 2019-25 — whose final-season median was 9.3 YPA.
- Manning ranks near the bottom of that first-round group in yards per attempt, average depth of target, passing grade, and EPA per dropback, while sitting near the top in time to throw.
- Manning holds the ball an average of 3.19 seconds but throws to an average depth of just 8.3 yards — peers like Anthony Richardson (11.5 aDOT), Justin Fields (10.4), Kenny Pickett (9.7) and Caleb Williams (9.2) turned similar patience into deeper shots.
- Manning's turnover-worthy play rate has improved from 3.5% last year to 2.5% this season, and his 14.8% pressure-to-sack rate beats the first-round median — making the disconnect between patience and production the central issue.
- Recent first-round history offers counter-examples on both sides: Zach Wilson posted a 95.5 PFF grade with 33 TDs and still flopped, while Justin Herbert (8.0 YPA), Jordan Love (17 INTs) and Anthony Richardson (53% completion) made it on physical tools alone.
- The late-college-career leap precedent — Joe Burrow at LSU, Jayden Daniels in year two, and Cam Ward entering his final season with Day-3 measurables — sets the bar Manning must clear over the remaining schedule.
Why it matters: With the NFL increasingly modeling draft decisions on advanced metrics like aDOT and EPA per dropback, Manning's three-game profile currently sits in the same statistical neighborhood as Daniel Jones — a cautionary comparable for any team weighing the No. 1 pick. The clock matters: if Manning doesn't produce more explosive plays from extended dropbacks over the next two months, his draft-stock ceiling could slip below the No. 1 consensus before December.
Ask SkimNews
